...
Cost & ProcurementFacility Management

How to Evaluate a Commercial Cleaning Proposal: A Side-by-Side Checklist

Executive Answer

Compare cleaning proposals on what they will actually deliver, not just the monthly total. A strong proposal comes from a real walkthrough and spells out the scope by area, the frequency of each task, the labor hours it assumes, who supervises, how misses are fixed, and what the contract includes. If two quotes are far apart, the difference is almost always in the hours and the scope, and the low one is usually the one that cut them.

ATEB technician high dusting an office entry with an extension duster in Nashua, NH

Table of Contents

Why price-only comparisons go wrong

Most buyers line up the quotes and look at the bottom line. It feels logical, but it is where most cleaning problems start.

Two proposals for the same building can differ by 40% or more and still list almost the same tasks. The difference is in what the paper does not say: how much time the crew will actually spend, how often each area gets attention, and who checks the work. A proposal is a plan for how the work will be done. The price only makes sense next to that plan.

The proposal checklist

A strong proposal includesRed flag if it’s missing or vague
A scope broken down by area (offices, restrooms, kitchens, entrances, floors)One generic task list for the whole building
Frequency for each task: nightly, weekly, monthly, periodic“General cleaning, 3x/week” with no detail
The labor hours per visit the price assumesNo hours, or a price with no way to check the time behind it
Who supervises, and how often they are on siteNo mention of supervision or quality checks
How misses are reported and how fast they are fixedNo response commitment
Periodic work (carpet, floors, high dusting): included or priced separatelySilence on periodic work, which often shows up later as extras
Supplies: who provides trash liners, paper, soapSupplies left unclear
A certificate of insuranceReluctance to provide a certificate of insurance
Contract terms: start date, notice period, how scope changes are pricedLong lock-in with no performance exit

The most useful question: how many labor hours per visit?

Ask every bidder the same question: how many labor hours per visit is your price based on?

This turns quotes you cannot compare into numbers you can. If one company plans four hours a night and another plans two for the same scope, you have found the real difference between them. The two-hour bid is not more efficient; it simply cannot do the same work. Low bids often look attractive at signing and then show up as missed tasks, rushed crews, and turnover a few months in.

It also works the other way. If a high bid assumes far more hours than the building needs, ask what those hours are for.

For how labor hours translate into price in Massachusetts and New Hampshire, see our commercial cleaning cost guide.

A good proposal starts with a real walkthrough

The walkthrough is where an accurate proposal comes from. A quick tour and a square-footage estimate produce a generic quote. A proper walkthrough should include:

  1. Why you are looking. What is not working now, and what you expect to be different.
  2. What “clean” means for you. Which areas matter most, and which can be cleaned less often.
  3. A real look at the building: cleanable space, floor types, restroom fixture counts, kitchens, entrances, glass, and how traffic moves.
  4. Access and timing: after-hours windows, alarms, keys, and areas the crew must avoid.
  5. How problems get reported and who your contact will be.

If a company prices your building without asking these questions, its proposal is built on assumptions.

How a scope should be built

A scope is the plan the crew works from every night. Good scopes are organized by how often work happens:

  • Nightly or every visit: trash, restrooms cleaned and restocked, high-touch surfaces, entrances, kitchens.
  • Weekly or rotating: detailed vacuuming, floor care, dusting beyond touch points, interior glass spots.
  • Periodic: high dusting, carpet extraction, floor scrubbing and refinishing.

Square footage is only the start. Layout, floor types, restroom counts, and traffic decide how long the work takes. Two buildings of the same size can need very different scopes. For typical frequencies by facility type, see how often a commercial facility should be cleaned.

Why quotes vary so much

Large price differences for what looks like the same job usually come from:

  • Hours: the time each bidder assumes per visit.
  • Scope detail: what is actually included, especially periodic work.
  • Supervision and quality control: whether someone checks the work.
  • Overhead: insurance, training, and the systems that make service consistent.

A higher price is not automatically better either. The question is always whether the price matches the scope and the hours.

Before you compare proposals, make sure each company means the same thing by the service it is quoting. Our guide to office cleaning vs. janitorial services explains where the two overlap and where they differ.

Questions to ask every bidder

  • How many labor hours per visit is this price based on?
  • Who supervises the crew, and how often are they on site?
  • How do we report a problem, and how fast is it fixed?
  • What is included for floors, carpets, and high dusting, and what is extra?
  • Who provides supplies?
  • Can you send a certificate of insurance?
  • What happens in the first 30 days?

How ATEB builds a proposal

Every ATEB janitorial proposal starts with a walkthrough and a written scope by area. We price by the labor hours the scope actually requires, and we tell you approximately how many hours your building will take to clean, so you can compare us to anyone else on the same terms. Misses are resolved within 24 hours, and usually much sooner, often the same day, with a corrective action so they don’t repeat. Quality checks are part of every account, for as long as we clean the building, not just the first few weeks. Need daytime coverage too? We can add a day porter to the same scope.

Frequently asked questions

What should a commercial cleaning proposal include?

A scope by area, a frequency for each task, the labor hours the price assumes, supervision and quality checks, how misses are fixed, what periodic work is included, supplies, insurance, and contract terms.

Why are cleaning quotes so different for the same building?

Mostly because bidders assume different labor hours and different scope detail. Ask each one how many hours per visit their price is based on.

Is the lowest cleaning bid a bad idea?

Not always, but a bid far below the others usually assumes fewer hours or a thinner scope. Compare the hours before choosing it.

How long should a cleaning walkthrough take?

Long enough to see every area, count restrooms and fixtures, check floor types, and discuss access and expectations. A five-minute tour cannot produce an accurate scope.

Should we ask for a certificate of insurance?

Yes. Any commercial cleaning contractor should be able to provide one before starting.

Get a proposal you can actually compare

We’ll measure your building, write a scope by area, and tell you approximately how many hours your building will take to clean. Schedule a walkthrough.

Does your facility need daytime cleaning support?

ATEB can evaluate demand periods, priority areas, porter responsibilities, and the handoff with after-hours cleaning.

Continue exploring

Staffing & QACleaning Operations
Every cleaning company misses something eventually. What matters is the response: how fast it's fixed, whether the cause is found, and whether it happens again.
Company News
ATEB Cleaning Services has refreshed its brand with a new logo, new colors, an updated website and the tagline Compliance-Driven. Facility-Focused. Same team, same standards.
Cost & ProcurementFacility Management
Low commercial cleaning prices usually mean fewer labor hours, thinner scope or no supervision. Here is how to compare bids and what a cheap program really costs.
Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.